| Year | Name |
|---|---|
| 1951 | M. O. Best |
| 1952 | Walter W. Knorpp |
| 1952 | Joseph Lanser |
| 1953 | Hugh C. Gruwell |
| 1954 | James Coles, L.E. |
| 1955 | Julius C. Wetzler |
| 1956 | Walter R. Bimson |
| 1957 | Earl C. Recker |
| 1958 | Walter E. Craig |
| 1959 | John Jacobs |
| 1960 | Arthur E. Burgher Jr. |
| 1961 | John B. Mills |
| 1962 | Rudy Lavik |
| 1963 | Samuel H. Morris |
| 1964 | Hugh Long |
| 1965 | Lewis J. Ruskin |
| 1966 | Daniel E. Noble |
| 1967 | Francis N. Connolly |
| 1968 | Harry Rosenzweig |
| 1969 | Kathryn K. Gammage |
| 1969 | Allen L. Rosenberg |
| 1970 | Arthur B. Schellenberg |
| 1971 | Miles W. Casteel |
| 1972 | James E. Patrick Sr. |
| 1973 | Herbert G. Fales |
| 1973 | Harold C. Giss (posthumously) |
| 1974 | Harold J. Barclay |
| 1975 | John Eversole |
| 1976 | Nina Murphy |
| 1977 | E. Ray Cowden |
| 1978 | Jack W. Whiteman |
| 1979 | Olivia H. Birchett |
| 1980 | Roderick J. "Rod" McMullin |
| 1981 | Rudy E. Campbell |
| 1981 | Howard Pyle |
| 1982 | Galen M. "Solly" Sollenberger |
| 1983 | Robert F. Menke |
| 1984 | Alan V. F. duBois |
| 1984 | Darrow "Duke" Tully |
| 1985 | Katherine K. "Kax" and G. Robert Herberger |
| 1986 | Burton S. Barr |
| 1987 | Budd L. Peabody |
| 1988 | David C. and Joan R. Lincoln |
| 1989 | Robert H. Duckworth |
| 1990 | William R. Shover |
| 1991 | None |
| 1992 | None |
| 1993 | Karl F. Abel |
| 1993 | Anne Linderman |
| 1995 | The Francis Family (Margaret F., Gesford & Joan, James S. Jr. "Jack" & Carol |
| 1996 | Raymond O. Clark |
| 1997 | Bernita M. "Bea" Steffl |
| 1998 | Sharon J. Harper |
| 1999 | Evelyn W. "Pit" Lucking |
| 2000 | Edward N. "Eddie" Basha |
| 2001 | Robert C. "Coach" Fleming |
| 2001 | Jerry Nelson |
| 2002 | Robin McMullen Hanna |
| 2005 | Joe Woods |
| 2006 | Dick and Dinky Snell |
| 2006 | Paul Eckstein |
| 2007 | William "Wink" Ames |
| 2008 | Armando B. Flores |
| 2009 | Migs Woodside |
| 2009 | Donald Budinger |
| 2010 | Special Presentation: The Quarterbacks |
| 2011 | Frank Kush & His Teams |
| 2012 | Special Presentation: NFL |
| 2013 | Ring of Honor |
| 2014 | Tim Healey and Ring of Honor |
| 2015 | Win Holden |
| 2016 | Dr. Wyatt W. Decker M.D. |
| 2017 | Tim Hovik |
| 2018 | Ray Schey |
| 2019 | Joann Holland |
| 2021 | William Sheaffer |