1951 M. O. Best
1952 Walter W. Knorpp
Joseph Lanser
1953 Hugh C. Gruwell
1954 James Coles, L.E.
1955 Julius C. Wetzler
1956 Walter R. Bimson
1957 Earl C. Recker
1958 Walter E. Craig
1959 John Jacobs
1960 Arthur E. Burgher Jr.
1961 John B. Mills
1962 Rudy Lavik
1963 Samuel H. Morris
1964 Hugh Long
1965 Lewis J. Ruskin
1966 Daniel E. Noble
1967 Francis N. Connolly
1968 Harry Rosenzweig
1969 Kathryn K. Gammage
Allen L. Rosenberg
1970 Arthur B. Schellenberg
1971 Miles W. Casteel
1972 James E. Patrick Sr.
1973 Herbert G. Fales
Harold C. Giss (posthumously)
1974 Harold J. Barclay
1975 John Eversole
1976 Nina Murphy
1977 E. Ray Cowden
1978 Jack W. Whiteman
1979 Olivia H. Birchett
1980 Roderick J. "Rod" McMullin
1981 Rudy E. Campbell
Howard Pyle
1982 Galen M. "Solly" Sollenberger
1983 Robert F. Menke
1984 Alan V. F. duBois
Darrow "Duke" Tully
1985 Katherine K. "Kax" and G. Robert Herberger
1986 Burton S. Barr
1987 Budd L. Peabody
1988 David C. and Joan R. Lincoln
1989 Robert H. Duckworth
1990 William R. Shover
1991 None
1992 None
1993 Karl F. Abel
Anne Linderman
1995 The Francis Family (Margaret F., Gesford & Joan, James S. Jr. "Jack" & Carol
1996 Raymond O. Clark
1997 Bernita M. "Bea" Steffl
1998 Sharon J. Harper
1999 Evelyn W. "Pit" Lucking
2000 Edward N. "Eddie" Basha
2001 Robert C. "Coach" Fleming
Jerry Nelson
2002 Robin McMullen Hanna
2005 Joe Woods
2006 Dick and Dinky Snell
Paul Eckstein
2007 William "Wink" Ames
2008 Armando B. Flores
2009 Migs Woodside
Donald Budinger
2010 Special Presentation: The Quarterbacks
2011 Frank Kush & His Teams
2012 Special Presentation: NFL
2013 Ring of Honor
2014 Tim Healey and Ring of Honor
2015 Win Holden
2017 Tim Hovik
2018 Ray Schey
2019 Joann Holland
2021 William Sheaffer